Pizza My Way

Reviews

• Kelly K.

  star star star star star 6 June 2026

  Hands down, the BEST little pizza place in the Bay Area. We love the chicken pizza and the wings are a thing of beauty! Perfectly seasoned, and no offensive weird orange type sauce, just good wings that fall off the bone.
  We've been ordering from here for years.
  
  The Greek salad is substantial and delicious, with black olives, artichoke hearts, sliced meats and feta cheese. It comes dry, so it's easy to add your own dressing, and what's ever left over, make a yummy Greek wrap the next day with!
  
  The owner and his staff are professional and the most friendly I've found. I got a call on my online order, directly on the phone, he wanted to make sure I picked up everything straight out of the oven! Now that's quality.
  
  Thank you!! See you again soon.

• Crowden S.

  star star star star star_border 4 June 2026

  Excellent pizza. A much wider variety of pizzas than the norm. Their Greek salad is enormous and very tasty, with large chunks of marinated artichoke hearts, slices of hand and salami, black olives, feta cheese (nice feta too!) etc.  The pizza had a great crust. Not a floppy oily mess as is often the case but not hard and crunchy either. Someway found the sweet point of firm enough to hold the slice in your hand yet still have a soft and chewy texture. Thumbs up!
  
  Very friendly service. Quite small inside and I suspect that the majority of the pizzas are made for take away, not eating in. Tables are clean and food is served promptly.
  
  Refreshments are sodas and waters, no beer or wine. One TV at the back. Parking in the lot outside or in neighboring lots with a short walk.
  
  Definitely a good experience and one worth repeating.

• Kevin H.

  star star star star star_border 13 May 2026

  This was my first visit and I was craving pizza which means it was time to visit YELP!
  
  Yelp sent me to ethos joint and I'm grateful.  This was a good pizza though certainly not a 5-star food experience I must say the level of service was exceptional.  Not sure I've ever seen someone so attentive to me and my order at a pizza place, ever.
  
  So I give the pizza four stars and will definitely return even if there may be better pizza nearby because the service was awesome.

• Chris Y.

  star star star star star_border 10 May 2026

  From everything I've heard about their pizza, it's always been good things, so I looked forward to what would be in store for me.
  
  Parking is generally pretty good, and not too difficult to find parking. If you're coming from the side of the Sun Valley Mall, it's just a left turn, or U-turn into the shopping center, but the U-turn would be closer as you don't need to drive down that side street for a little bit to actually get into the plaza.
  
  Pizza My Way accepts online ordering through Yelp, or if it's easier (or you just prefer to talk to a person), it'll be an easy call, and they pick up fast to take the order. Timing is about on time, give or take 5-10 minutes off, but this was my first time here, so take it for what it's worth anecdotally.
  
  The decor of the place is much different than it was a boba/crepe shop. Half of the shop is now closed off as the kitchen part of the place. When you arrive, make sure you don't go into the wrong door, although, usually the kitchen staff are back there anyways, so you probably won't make that mistake before someone stops you, but just in case. If you see a bunch of kitchen equipment and dough lying around, you're at the wrong entrance. When you make your way to the front door, it's a fairly small little counter front. But it's fitting for a nice quiet meal, especially if you're dropping in for lunch. It has a few small tables both inside the establishment, as well as some tables outside. Seems like it would be a nice little place to be during lunch breaks on weekdays, but don't quote me on that since I've yet to been during those times. Menus are straight forward, and overall the selection is great, with of course the customizable options at your disposal. Price wise, it's on par with most of the pizza places around, with the exception of the make your own pizza places, but you will realize soon that there is no comparison to those at this place.
  
  Today I ordered a half Chicken Masterpiece, and a half meat lovers. I ordered for take out, so when I got there, it was still a bit of a wait, but nothing major, and gave me time to look around a bit anyways.
  
  I'm going to break down the food by dough and toppings/sauces.
  
  First, the dough. I mean, it's probably one of the more delicious dough I've had in awhile from a pizza place. Not too hard/dry, not too doughy/wet, it was just right for my liking. You can pick up the slice without the slice completely slanting down on you, but it's also hefty enough that it'll stay relatively straight for consumption. And there are times when I dread eating the crust from certain pizza establishments, but this time was not one of those instances, and I was more than happy to scarf down every bit of the slices.
  
  The meat lovers toppings were all delicious. The sauce is just a tomato sauce, and it did it's job, so no complaint there. The meats that were on the pizza though were flavorful, plentiful, and overall, just was satisfyingly meaty. The texture of the meat here was certainly different than many places. I feel this may be contributed to the fact that many of their meats are beef or turkey based (for things that are usually pork), so it plays around with the texture of what I'm eating. It's a nice touch, and goes great with the pizza.
  
  The chicken masterpiece I felt really shined. It hands down my favorite of the two halves. If only I was able to pop some of the sausage too onto the chicken masterpiece, it would've been over, but I'm happy to settle for the chicken masterpiece as it is now. The sauces that were used in the chicken masterpiece, and the way it worked together with the cheese on top was indeed...masterful. All the toppings that were on it just added to what was a symphony of flavor (I know, corny huh?), and just tasted so creamy, and continually appetizing. The chicken wasn't overcooked, as chicken often seems to have this issue when it's on a pizza, but at Pizza My Way, there are no such issues. For chicken lovers, I'd definitely recommend giving this a try if you're new to the place, or if you're a frequenter who has yet to give it a snacking on.
  
  Pizza My Way is a great place to be if you're looking for a well done slice/slices of pizza for your meal. From the dough, to sauces, to the cheese, to the toppings, everything just worked in harmony together to make what was a yum time coming for me and this establishment.
  
  My only complaint was that my chicken masterpiece seemed to have been off in one of the corners on the pizza. It wasn't very consistent, and those two pieces were mainly just cheese, and not a lot of chicken, or any of the other toppings I should have gotten. You can see from the picture it just looked like someone gave up around that point, lol.
  
  Again, minor thing, but still wished it would've been more consistent since everything else was almost perfect. I will be back!

• Maryam B.

  star star star star star 9 May 2026

  I frequently order over the phone and in the restaurant! They have the BEST BEEF PEPPERONI! Love this spot!